They are so busy because they’re so good. They are well staffed and everyone is patient and kind. Onto the food, I’m from NYC and hands down the best pizza I have had out west. Management is professional and fair as well as prices. 10000/10 recommend.
Andrew O'Barton
-
September 21, 2023
Went around 3 o'clock on a Monday. Place was slow. I ordered two slices of pepperoni, but they never heated up the slices. Ended up waiting like 30 minutes. I will say however, the pizza was some of the best I've had in Colorado. Actually prefer it to Krazy Karl's.
Connie
-
April 30, 2022
Great pizza, delicious overstuffed calzones, yummy spicy ranch sauce, wonderful atmosphere and fun outgoing staff! What more could you ask of a pizza place. Love the tiled tabletops and the upbeat music. The place was clean and quiet when we arrived but by about 8pm it was packed full of college students so the noise went way up. It didn't bother us but if you're looking for a spot to dine-in that isn't too loud then go earlier in the evening. It is next to a college campus after all. Or just order and take it to go. The pizza is some of the best we've had, top 3 for sure. My husband even said it was better than an (unnamed) famous pizza place in Times Square we recently visited. He raved about the Calzone that was overstuffed with his favorite fillings instead of being half air and mostly cheese and ricotta. This one had the meats piled up! My son had the chicken salad with ranch which he said was better then he thought it would be. The rest of us had pepperoni pizza and sausage and bacon pizza. The staff was super nice and friendly to us. Very much enjoyed the interaction.
Jack
-
September 06, 2023
Great size Pizza slice for the price. Best crust in town and a good variety. Spicy ranch is a must. Don't go to Pizza hut or dominoes go here!
Carsen Bahn
-
July 19, 2023
Would be nice if they had an area or place to get take out or sign directing so you don’t have to stand in line with people ordering. My order was ready but stood in line for 10 minutes to pick up order.
Our Address
1401 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins, CO 80521, USA
Get Directions
Ad 2
Ads Title
Claim Listing: Cosmo’s Pizza
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
They are so busy because they’re so good. They are well staffed and everyone is patient and kind. Onto the food, I’m from NYC and hands down the best pizza I have had out west. Management is professional and fair as well as prices. 10000/10 recommend.
Went around 3 o'clock on a Monday. Place was slow. I ordered two slices of pepperoni, but they never heated up the slices. Ended up waiting like 30 minutes. I will say however, the pizza was some of the best I've had in Colorado. Actually prefer it to Krazy Karl's.
Great pizza, delicious overstuffed calzones, yummy spicy ranch sauce, wonderful atmosphere and fun outgoing staff! What more could you ask of a pizza place. Love the tiled tabletops and the upbeat music. The place was clean and quiet when we arrived but by about 8pm it was packed full of college students so the noise went way up. It didn't bother us but if you're looking for a spot to dine-in that isn't too loud then go earlier in the evening. It is next to a college campus after all. Or just order and take it to go. The pizza is some of the best we've had, top 3 for sure. My husband even said it was better than an (unnamed) famous pizza place in Times Square we recently visited. He raved about the Calzone that was overstuffed with his favorite fillings instead of being half air and mostly cheese and ricotta. This one had the meats piled up! My son had the chicken salad with ranch which he said was better then he thought it would be. The rest of us had pepperoni pizza and sausage and bacon pizza. The staff was super nice and friendly to us. Very much enjoyed the interaction.
Great size Pizza slice for the price. Best crust in town and a good variety. Spicy ranch is a must. Don't go to Pizza hut or dominoes go here!
Would be nice if they had an area or place to get take out or sign directing so you don’t have to stand in line with people ordering. My order was ready but stood in line for 10 minutes to pick up order.