Great pizza, delicious overstuffed calzones, yummy spicy ranch sauce, wonderful atmosphere and fun outgoing staff! What more could you ask of a pizza place. Love the tiled tabletops and the upbeat music. The place was clean and quiet when we arrived but by about 8pm it was packed full of college students so the noise went way up. It didn't bother us but if you're looking for a spot to dine-in that isn't too loud then go earlier in the evening. It is next to a college campus after all. Or just order and take it to go. The pizza is some of the best we've had, top 3 for sure. My husband even said it was better than an (unnamed) famous pizza place in Times Square we recently visited. He raved about the Calzone that was overstuffed with his favorite fillings instead of being half air and mostly cheese and ricotta. This one had the meats piled up! My son had the chicken salad with ranch which he said was better then he thought it would be. The rest of us had pepperoni pizza and sausage and bacon pizza. The staff was super nice and friendly to us. Very much enjoyed the interaction.
Hayden Filsinger
-
January 19, 2023
The food is great and reasonably priced. Half of the employees are great people who make fun small talk, but there are some employees here that don't get along with me. They seemed to handle it professionally and treat me kindly, but I feel unsettled and will not be returning.
Jesse Raikes
-
August 23, 2021
I just pulled into Fort Collins after a drive from steamboat and my nephew said go get Cosmos Pizza, get the spicy ranch dipping sauce.. Well, I had 10 minutes left before they were closing, I called in to see if they still had slices.. And bingo, massive sized slices, great dipping sauce and all nice employees! Got the 32oz drink to keep a souvenir cup from the place as well. Definitely worth it!
The pic is the slices out of the case, not warmed up, didn't want to hold them up during their closing time.. Quarter there to show size comparison.
Jacob Friedman
-
January 18, 2023
While the price is decent and it is fast delivery, the one item I ordered was incorrect. I had ordered a simple pepperoni pizza, and was delivered a plain cheese pizza. While it isn’t the end of the world, I just wanted a pepperoni pizza, and was charged for one as well!
Leanne Lorson
-
February 06, 2023
All the things you want from pizza delivery: on time, consistent quality, reliable, delicious, fresh, food shows up hot, and such nice staff! This is now my go-to for pizza night.
Our Address
1401 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins, CO 80521, USA
Get Directions
Ad 2
Ads Title
Claim Listing: Cosmo’s Pizza
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Great pizza, delicious overstuffed calzones, yummy spicy ranch sauce, wonderful atmosphere and fun outgoing staff! What more could you ask of a pizza place. Love the tiled tabletops and the upbeat music. The place was clean and quiet when we arrived but by about 8pm it was packed full of college students so the noise went way up. It didn't bother us but if you're looking for a spot to dine-in that isn't too loud then go earlier in the evening. It is next to a college campus after all. Or just order and take it to go. The pizza is some of the best we've had, top 3 for sure. My husband even said it was better than an (unnamed) famous pizza place in Times Square we recently visited. He raved about the Calzone that was overstuffed with his favorite fillings instead of being half air and mostly cheese and ricotta. This one had the meats piled up! My son had the chicken salad with ranch which he said was better then he thought it would be. The rest of us had pepperoni pizza and sausage and bacon pizza. The staff was super nice and friendly to us. Very much enjoyed the interaction.
The food is great and reasonably priced. Half of the employees are great people who make fun small talk, but there are some employees here that don't get along with me. They seemed to handle it professionally and treat me kindly, but I feel unsettled and will not be returning.
I just pulled into Fort Collins after a drive from steamboat and my nephew said go get Cosmos Pizza, get the spicy ranch dipping sauce.. Well, I had 10 minutes left before they were closing, I called in to see if they still had slices.. And bingo, massive sized slices, great dipping sauce and all nice employees! Got the 32oz drink to keep a souvenir cup from the place as well. Definitely worth it! The pic is the slices out of the case, not warmed up, didn't want to hold them up during their closing time.. Quarter there to show size comparison.
While the price is decent and it is fast delivery, the one item I ordered was incorrect. I had ordered a simple pepperoni pizza, and was delivered a plain cheese pizza. While it isn’t the end of the world, I just wanted a pepperoni pizza, and was charged for one as well!
All the things you want from pizza delivery: on time, consistent quality, reliable, delicious, fresh, food shows up hot, and such nice staff! This is now my go-to for pizza night.